I should tell you up front that I've never seen anything by Tim Burton before (as I've never had the desire) and I am a far cry from being a Johnny Depp fan. (I don't dislike him but he's never played a character in a way to make me like him either. I like people who make me like them.) So I went in predisposed to the following:
1. Not to care much about Tim Burton's imagination;
2. Not to care much about Johnny Depp's performance; and
3. Not caring whether or not the story held true to Lewis Carroll's original tale.
That all declared, I give this film neither a thumbs up or a thumbs down. It was weird which I feel was the point and purpose of the entire movie so it didn't fail to miss the mark with me. Then again, I've always found Carroll's story weird and endearing. It's a strange mix of imagination and hallucination and, not being terribly attached to the storyline, I don't really care too much what various interpretations people give to it. (Unlike Anne where if you stray a jot or tittle, I'd like to have your hide!) I did very much enjoy Frank Beddor's take on Alice in The Looking Glass Wars. I thought Burton kinda had the same idea and wondered if Beddor is grinding his teeth a little.
The movie was all I expected from a Burton film. Weirdness. (I should probably pick a better word but I kinda think that one is just about right!) Strange characters who are over dramatized. Characters who are painted to look freakish or hilarious, depending on how you are predisposed to approach something which is pointedly unusual.
I thought the following line from the film said it best, in terms of Burton's worldview:
This quote was used twice in the film and when I googled it I found a lot of people who identified with it. I find this most interesting. You can google the phrase, "Quotes from Tim Burton's Alice in Wonderland" and it comes up with some random, inconsequential remarks. But if you google this specific quote from the film, teenagers everywhere are 'going mad' themselves over it, trying to find ways to fit it into their every day conversations."Have I gone mad?"- Hatter"I'm afraid so, you're entirely bonkers. But I'll tell you a secret... all the best people are."- Alice Kingsley.
I think the popularity of this quote kind of indicates why this film should be watched with caution. Certainly we should be discerning about every thing we set before our eyes. I walked out of the movie theater feeling like Burton was trying to make a point: "Unique and mildly crazy is good." Another way to say that is, "Let's all do what's right in our own eyes." Because there was nothing typical about this particular cinematic experience, (instead coming across as rather audacious and in-your-face), I would say that this movie most strongly argues for individuality and sensationalism. It's kind of like the ten year old boy who wants to dye his hair purple and spike it just to marinate in the idea that he has shocked the adults and has their undivided attentions. And it works! This is why Tim Burton is making lots of money (and I, for the record, am not.)
Now, from the standpoint of going to the movies just to be entertained, we were that! We probably both enjoyed the first half of the movie better than the second half. Burton opens his story well and the costumes were really quite fantastical. It boggles the mind how much work went into birthing such visions of creativity in bringing well-known (and yet not known) characters to life.
Speaking of the characters - I thought I would have managed to like the Queen of Hearts a little better if she had consistently made use of her lisp. (It came and went and I couldn't predict when I'd hear it next which was mildly disconcerting.) I didn't care for the White Queen (played by Anne Hathaway) at all. I thought she was just plain ridiculous. I DID like Alice and if Depp had been more toned down I might have been able to say that I liked the Mad Hatter. But since I was being told by Burton to like everyone because they were crazy, it turns out that I hardly liked anyone at all. Instead, I found the entertainment solely in the storyline which WAS unique and creative and - dare I say it - fun?
The premise of the movie is great (in my opinion.) Alice is a bright and imaginative young girl who is being offered a proposal of marriage that society thinks she should not refuse. Alice, however, has hesitations and instead of marriage she chases a rabbit down a hole. You probably know where she goes from there. Instead of just exploring Wonderland though, it turns out she's been purposefully called in this strange new world to do battle against the Red Queen's Jabberwalky. Instead of a tripping around Tweedledum and Tweedledee (Disney-fied) it's Alice running from danger and trying to restore the White Queen to the throne. It's adventurous and suspenseful and I DID like that. I thought Burton did a good job making "Wonderland" feel like that was exactly what it was supposed to be called.
Whether or not you would like the film is anyone's guess. I don't think it is so crazy a movie that it is to be avoided. However, I do think it is so crazy that anyone watching it should be careful and discerning about the message behind the movie. (For, to be sure, there are messages even when you aren't specifically looking for them!) For a date night out - it was fun and it gave us lots to talk about. As a way to just escape reality and relax? (Wait. Isn't that what date nights are for?!?!) Well, it's not a movie that I think you can just turn your brain off and sit through. There's too much there for one to think about and maybe that's one reason why the film hasn't been as successful as some hoped. It's SO crazy that your brain has to work overtime to take it all in and process it.
That said, if the most impressive thing you walked out of the theater with is the above quote I shared, then I suppose you've gotten the main point. Be unique. Be crazy. Be YOU. (Unless you are around ME and then I would beg you to tone it down a bit.)