Monday, January 12, 2015

Tales of Beedle the Bard, by J.K. Rowling

The Tales of Beedle the Bard appeared in our household around Christmastime. Being that it is a quick and easy read, I got right to it.

The Tales of Beedle the Bard are referenced in Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows. They are a collection of fairy tale like stories for wizards. Hermoine receives the book in hopes that she will use it to problem solve in the concluding adventure of the series. (I'm trying not to provide any spoilers in this description in case people haven't read about Harry Potter yet.) Rowling wrote The Tales of Beedle the Bard at the conclusion of the series in manuscript form. The book was printed in limited quantity with proceeds earmarked for charity. All proceeds were (are?) to be donated to the Children's High Level Group (now called Lumos). The book sold well to Potter fans and quite a bit of money was then donated to this fund.

This is definitely a book that you will want to read after reading the Harry Potter series, if you care to read it at all. (It's not necessary.) I would say that this book would be well-received by fans who just cannot get enough of Potter and will take any bone that Rowling will throw to them. Now, I've been honest in describing my Harry Potter journey. I started out an extreme skeptic and turned into a rabid fan. However, I don't find myself wanting more Potter for the sake of more Potter. I thought the original series was brilliantly written and concluded very nicely. I've not been tempted to look at the Pottermore website or wish for trips to Universal Studios to "experience the world of Harry Potter" or anything like that. A good series solidly written and concluded is immensely satisfying to me and I don't want to risk marring it with "add-ons" meant only to satisfy cravings.

Now that I've said all that, I should also add that The Tales of Beedle the Bard isn't bad. It just isn't Harry Potter; it's a tease. I could read it happily enough as a series of fairy tales, but not as a part of Potter's World. I like the way it was handled in The Deathly Hallows and didn't feel the need for illumination. I liken my love of the Potter series exclusively to the enjoyment of a good television show. A good series knows when to stop. (Once Upon a Time? You should have stopped so I could have loved you wholly and completely.)

In The Tales of Beedle the Bard we have five wizard fairy tales which are similar to those of muggles in that they have a moral. However, not all of these stories have a happy ending. (One of the stories is downright gruesome.) There is commentary from Albus Dumbledore explaining the history of each story and the point of its inclusion in the text. So Rowling is a clever in giving us a taste of Dumbledore and a few additional tales to think about but I find myself wishing to refrain so as not to accidentally take away my enjoyment of her meaty, delicious Harry Potter series.

I've heard from others that this is a "take it or leave it" book and I concur. It's not horrible but it also does not work in satisfying the itch for Potter for me. One day, likely not too far from now, I'll re-engage with the series as a whole and will enjoy it all over again. (Never the same way as the first time, I imagine, but still . . . ! I will enjoy it!) I guess I would categorize this book is a "nice thought" but left me feeling "blah" at the conclusion. Nothing but straight up Harry for me, thanks!

1 comment:

Cassandra said...

My husband is finally wrapping up the Harry Potter series. He's almost done with book six. Reading as I type. ;) I am still a huge skeptic of HP but respect that other people feel differently. I'm sure I'll discuss it with Jeff after he finishes the series. I already know how it ends; I cheated and looked it up because I knew I'd never read it. lol The only comment he's made so far about book six is that he hates the word "snogging." LOL

Top  blogs